Elfquest The Final Quest Volume 1 by Wendy, Richard Pini

Like so many fans, I was along for the ride from the beginning: back in the 1980s haunting my local comic shop every 3 months, hoping the newest issue was coming out. And then the Starblaze/Donner editions came out in glorious color and I considered myself one of the biggest Elfquest fans out there. Of course, eventually the troubles began at WaRP- Wendy worn out from her intricate drawing work, Richard constantly embattled with lawsuits and issues with the way he ran WaRP. But the tipping point for me was a Comic Con I attend in the 1990s just to meet the Pinis and get an issue signed; when I met Richard Pini at the WaRP booth, I gushed, I adored, and I was curtly told to buy a comic if I wanted a signature before his back turned on me in annoyance of bringing my own copy to be signed rather than buying from him. Crushed at being so summarily dismissed, I meekly bought the issue again and left without any signatures.


And then last month, I noticed “The Final Quest” has come out and hoped this hearkened back to the original series. There have been so many ‘Elfquest iterations’ through the years; many not worth the time to read and feeling more like poor fan art. Certainly, nothing came anywhere close to the original Quest over the years.

With this first volume of the Final Quest arc, the art finally feels like Wendy’s work. Granted, the details and intricacies are gone so somehow it admittedly seems more like a shadow of her work. But I’d rather have this than no Wendy at all, truth be told. So although the characters are true to the original Quest, I can’t help but feel a bit let down.

The stories, though, were honestly all over the place. The whole volume doesn’t come together like one story so much as little vignettes to close up storylines (Kahvi’s end, for example) or show new character births before they are grown up in volume 2 (e.g., Suntop’s daughter). Perhaps because this is a rebirth of Elfquest once again being a Pini enterprise, there is a running storyline of rebirth/childbirth. But with every 4 pages jumping between locations/timelines/characters, it feels very random and scattershot. I was hoping for one continual story as with the original Quest, I guess. I honestly couldn’t keep track of the characters, there were just too many.

Perhaps owing to the modern times, the coloring and varying line widths were very distracting. Characters changed looks a lot as a result; I can’t help but feel that although it is wonderful to have color, quality of the production was compromised somewhere as a result. It’s not a major thing and certainly doesn’t overly detract; but it is there.

Will I continue to follow The Final Quest? Definitely. Already by volume 2 the story begins to coalesce a bit more and isn’t as jumpy as before. But the rushed scattershot storytelling continues, unfortunately. Precious few pages given to each little scene that could honestly have been stretched out to be far more satisfying.

This entry was posted in Book Reviews, Fantasy, graphic novel. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Elfquest The Final Quest Volume 1 by Wendy, Richard Pini

  1. Nancy says:

    OMG, someone who loves ElfQuest! I have loved this series since the 90’s and have all the original comics and graphic novels. When artists beside Wendy Pini got too involved, I stopped buying them, but got reinterested in “The Final Quest”. I agree that the storylines are all over the place, they are trying to cram every character ever introduced into the story and give them some sort of closure. My review on the first book: https://graphicnovelty2.com/2016/03/04/elfquest-book-1/

  2. Nancy says:

    BTW, I have heard scuttlebutt about Richard Pini’s attitude too.

    • Online Eccentric Librarian says:

      Yeah – I think Pini’s attitude has been well documented as being difficult – from coworkers through to artists who have worked under WaRP. But yeah – that Comic Con with my sister where, as adults, we wanted to tell him how much Elfquest meant to us growing up – and he pretty much treated us like annoying pests for gushing about how much we love his series – when he just wanted to sell stuff, I guess. On the plus side, Wendy did a drawing for an audience of Cutter that was cool to watch. Remember when they previewed stories at the end of the comics for other titles?

      • Nancy says:

        I always wondered about the first Wave Dancers debacle. All the clues pointed to some behind the scenes upset, and hearing how RP is hard to deal with, I assume the working relationship between the artists couldn’t be salvaged. I was upset at the time, since I liked the first set of water elves, but I grew to love the new official Pini water elves too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s